How to choose a organizational design consultant?
Choosing an organizational design consultant starts with defining the business problem. Are decisions taking too long? Do teams duplicate work? Has growth or an acquisition left responsibilities unclear? A new org chart may be part of the answer, but the consultant should first understand what the organization needs to accomplish and how work happens today.
The strongest candidates can explain how they will diagnose the problem, design a workable structure, and help your team put it into practice. Use these six criteria to evaluate them.
1. Look for a clear link between strategy and daily work
Ask each consultant how they translate strategic goals into changes employees will experience. A useful answer should address the work the company must perform, the capabilities it needs, and the decisions people must make. Be cautious if the proposed approach begins and ends with reporting lines.
Ask: “How will you determine whether our current structure is preventing us from executing our strategy?”
2. Examine how they study processes
Roles are difficult to design well without understanding the work assigned to them. A consultant should examine important workflows, handoffs, bottlenecks, and points where ownership becomes unclear. This is especially valuable when several functions contribute to the same customer or operational outcome.
Ask: “Which processes would you review before recommending a new structure?”
3. Make decision rights and accountability explicit
An organizational chart shows reporting relationships. It does not, by itself, settle who approves a decision, who owns a result, or when an issue should be escalated. Ask how the consultant will define these responsibilities and test whether leaders understand them consistently.
Ask: “What will you deliver beyond an org chart to clarify ownership and decision making?”
4. Match their experience to your company’s situation
An enterprise-wide redesign, a private equity portfolio company integration, and a middle market business preparing to scale present different challenges. Look for relevant experience with your company’s size, pace, and reason for change. Ask for examples that show the consultant’s role and the decisions their work helped a client make.
Ask: “What similar situation have you worked on, and what changed as a result?”
5. Understand how they will evaluate the proposed design
A consultant should be able to explain the tradeoffs between design options. How will each option affect management capacity, operating cost, customer service, speed, or accountability? Ask what data and assumptions they will use, and how they will test a proposed structure before implementation.
Ask: “How will we know whether the future organization is likely to perform better?”
6. Confirm who will help implement the change
The work does not end when leadership approves a structure. Roles must be clarified, leaders aligned, employees informed, and changes to processes put into operation. Establish what implementation support is included and who from the consulting team will remain involved.
Ask: “What happens between approval of the design and the point when teams are working in the new model?”
What should an organizational design engagement deliver?
The deliverables should fit the problem, but a practical engagement may include:
An assessment of the current structure, workflows, and accountability gaps
Clear design principles tied to business goals
Options for the future operating model and organizational structure
Defined roles, decision rights, and governance
A way to evaluate cost, capacity, and performance assumptions
An implementation plan with owners and milestones
Before selecting a consultant, ask to see a sample of comparable deliverables. You should understand what decisions you will be able to make with the work they provide.
Choosing a consultant for a middle market company
Middle market businesses often need to make organizational decisions while continuing to grow, serve customers, or integrate acquisitions. The right consultant should bring analytical discipline without creating a design that is too complicated to operate.
Stonehill approaches organizational design by examining how work gets done and connecting those processes to roles, accountability, and the org chart. If your company is scaling, integrating an acquisition, or struggling with unclear ownership, talk with Stonehill about your organizational design challenge.
Organizational Design Consulting Services
-
Develop clear organizational structures that align teams, functions, reporting relationships, and responsibilities with the company's strategy and goals.
-
Design how people, processes, technology, governance, and capabilities work together to support the organization's future-state business model.
-
Clarify roles, responsibilities, accountability, and ownership to reduce overlap, eliminate gaps, and improve organizational effectiveness.
-
Establish clear decision-making authority, governance structures, and escalation paths so leaders and teams can make decisions efficiently and consistently.
-
Evaluate organizational layers, management spans, and reporting structures to identify unnecessary complexity and create a more effective organization.
Let’s Work Together
Download our free, printable Guide to Design Thinking!
Design Thinking is one of the most valuable problem-solving methodologies an organization can adopt. The Stonehill team created the most simple and effective guide to arriving at human-centric business solutions, all based on our proven-to-work everyday Design Thinking practices.
This guide features different canvases with tutorials that walk you through the Design Thinking process in the most practical way. Fill out the form to immediately access Stonehill’s simple guide to Design Thinking and begin your team’s journey to empathetic problem-solving!
Learn more about Design Thinking: Stonehill’s guiding methodology.
